Geizhals interface quirks
Donnerstag, 29. September 2005Geizhals is a quite popular consumer-product site here in Austria. It can tell you where you will get your PC hardware, software, HiFi-stuff and so on for the cheapest price (I’m sure there are quite a lot of these sites around, so you will know what I’m talking about).
It also offers a nice feature for users who want to buy more than one piece of equipment: it lets you create so called “wish-lists” where you can store the interesting items for later use. However, one encounters at least two usability problems when using this cool service.
First of all, the site seems to store your ID by using a cookie by which it can identify you and find the suitable whish-list (you don’t have to create an account for using the wish-lists). This is fine on the one hand since you don’t have fill out a registration form and remember your login/password for future use.
On the other hand, you can’t access your wishlist from another PC, something I do quite often.
So an additional possibility for creating a “real” account would further enhance this useful functionality.
Next problem: the wish-list can be renamed or deleted. Great thing since this means that you can have different wish-lists for you PC hardware, your HiFi-stuff, your DVDs….
But the implementation of this functionality can be considered as a usability disaster. Look at the screenshot below:
Below the wish-list, there’s an input field as well as a button. You might think that the button and the field might belong together. The input field lets you enter the new name for your wish-list (labeled “rename this wish-list to:”). The button below the input field lets you delete your wish-list (labeled “delete”).
What happens?
Each time I want to rename my list, I hit the button below automatically, thereby deleting my list! It happens to me everytime I use this thing.
In order to rename your list, you just have to enter a new name and hit ENTER on your keyboard afterwards.
What should they do? They should seperate renaming and deleting on the interface. That’s all. And I’m sure I’m not the only one that unintendedly deletes his wish-lists all the time
.













